We have a new lesbian rabbi. I've noticed that some of the other congregants.... - JFCS of Greater Philadelphia

Dear Ally,

I belong to a reform synagogue. We have a new lesbian rabbi. I've noticed that some of the other congregants, a few who I would consider friends, have been vocal with their opinions. I fear that their negative attitudes and behavior will influence other congregants and make LGBTQ members feel isolated and not welcomed. I'm not sure how to address this.



Dear Concerned,

I’m so glad that you are concerned about this and care about making all congregants feel welcome at your synagogue. Certainly, if this negativity towards the rabbi because of her sexual orientation begins to spread through the congregation, even if it began with only a few people, it can cause other LGBTQ folks, and their family, friends, and allies, to doubt their welcome there. It is possible that you can address this in two ways. One way is to be openly supportive of the rabbi in general, commenting when you are appreciative of an interesting sermon she has given or class she has taught, complimenting a particularly moving service, or mentioning that she carried out some other rabbinic task with sensitivity, caring, and skill. Members of the congregation, both your critical friends and others, will hear your opinion and, hopefully, focus on the qualities that are important in a rabbi. Another way to address this, which is more difficult, would be to “confront” the critics next time you hear a negative comment and ask what they mean and why they are so negative about it. You can then counter their comments with your own positive reflections on the rabbi and even your concerns about making members feel unwelcome. Keshet at http://www.keshetonline.org is a great resource with a range of articles that may be helpful.This is a sensitive situation and you are right to be concerned. Some people might hesitate to speak out, and by their silence lend support to the rabbi’s detractors. Kudos to you for living your Jewish values of welcoming and inclusion.


Submit Your Question

  • Only the "Ask Your Question" field marked with * is required. All other fields are OPTIONAL.
  • All information is anonymous and confidential.
    A response will be directly sent to you if an email is provided.

JFCS Non-Discrimination Policy

ACAF Jewish Family and Children's Service of Greater Philadelphia 2015JFCS clients have a right to be treated with dignity and respect; free of all discrimination, including that which is based on race, age, sex, religion, sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, marital status, national origin, or disability; and not subject to any verbal, sexual, emotional, or physical abuse; or harsh or unfair treatment. To the extent possible, JFCS will make every reasonable accommodation to serve you consistent with our program services.

We are committed to affording opportunities to a diverse supplier base, while ensuring that JFCS receives the highest quality products and services at the most economical costs. JFCS desires to promote and enhance mutually beneficial business relationships within the diverse communities of which the Agency is a part. The Agency will make good faith efforts to utilize minority-owned, women-owned, disabled-owned businesses throughout the procurement processes. No preference will be given to any business group or classification.